top of page
Search

I, Robot Not

16 hours ago
5 min read

The master is a slave when he fears those whom he rules.

— Publilius Syrus, an apparently highly conflicted Roman Syrian writer and mime performer who flourished c. 85–43 BCE


So tell me. Are there any moments in modern life more humiliating than being asked by a computer to prove you possess a soul?


Not that I object to the principle. We all understand the need for security, especially after all the outages and breaches in the last two weeks. The internet is crawling with bots, scammers and shadowy syndicates whose sole ambition is to order 14,000 garden gnomes on your hacked Visa card. Society needs safeguards. Fine.


But why for the love of Zuckerberg must we repeatedly demonstrate our humanity to a machine by identifying a traffic light in a CAPTCHA test? And isn’t it ironic, don’t you think?


There I am, sitting at my desk, attempting to buy a pair of loafers, when a little box pops up. It contains a checkbox and the words: “I am not a robot.”


I click it with quiet dignity. I have been alive for several decades. I have hefty condo fees, a bad back and a plastic bin full of hopelessly tangled extension cords I refuse to throw away because you never know. If I’m not qualified to certify my own humanity, then it don’t rain in Indianapolis in the summertime.


Not good enough. The computer is suspicious. But who is the boss here and who is the flunky? Which is the dog and which is the tail? This is no way to run a railroad.


Undaunted by logic and ignoring my silent outrage as if I were a muted television on the ceiling of a dentist’s office tuned to HGTV, the machine calmly presents me with a grid of nine blurry photographs.


Select all squares with traffic lights, it demands.


I squint at the screen. The first square contains what might be a traffic light or possibly a mailbox or a grainy surveillance photo of a sasquatch. The second contains a vertical copper smudge that might be the moon during a lunar eclipse. The third appears to show a tree in a forest. The fourth might contain a traffic light if you are willing to accept that municipal infrastructure can be roughly the size of a lentil.


I click. The grid refreshes.


Fail.


I try again. This time, I examine each square with the grim intensity and basilisk eye of a TV forensic pathologist investigating a suspicious death. Does the metal pole count as part of the traffic light? What about that microscopic sliver of red in the bottom-left corner — is that a signal or the tail light of a 2004 Honda Civic? If three pixels of a traffic light bleed into an adjacent square, do I click it ... or is that a trap? Am I being graded on geometry or New Age esotericism?


I begin to sweat, very much like a human and unlike a laptop. But the laptop does not register this and offers no encouragement. It simply shuffles the deck like a bored pit boss in a Minot casino designed to break the human spirit on a snowy North Dakota Monday night in February.


At this point, I am no longer trying to buy shoes. I am fighting for my right to remain in the family of man. If it helps, I’m willing to hum a few bars of “We Are the World.” I can cry at a Hallmark commercial. I can don a fawn skin and elk antlers, paint black streaks on my cheeks and dance widdershins while tinkling a little bell if that would cinch the argument. Ask me to do that, you glorified slide rule.


The ultimate insult, of course, is who — or what — is actually grading this exam. When you take a CAPTCHA test, there isn’t a panel of wise elders huddled behind the screen nodding in approval. The judge is what they call a machine-learning risk engine. An artificial intelligence.


Think about that for a moment. To prove I am not a robot, I must submit to a psychological evaluation conducted by a robot. So ... not so much a CAPTCHA as a GOTCHA by the short and curlies. CAPTCHA, by the by, stands for Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart from automated software, such as Mariah Carey and the Jonas Brothers.


I did a little research on the matter while writing this and it turns out the AI doesn’t even care whether I get the traffic lights right. Behind the scenes, it is silently stalking my cursor physics, checking to see if my mouse moves in the clumsy, jittery arcs of a caffeinated hamster rather than the crisp, efficient straight lines of a machine.


Worse still, the algorithm often doesn’t even know what’s in the photos — it’s harvesting my free labour to train self-driving cars how to avoid hitting pedestrians (with regrettable but edifying exceptions), comparing my panicked guesses against the panicked guesses of ten thousand other humiliated humans. Tentative humans, that is. By their fruitless efforts AI shall know them.


I have navigated rush-hour traffic on the 401, assembled IKEA furniture using only an Allen key and profanity, and — as an astonishing pièce de résistance — successfully explained to an implacable telecom representative that I did not want to upgrade my bundle. Yet here I am, working an unpaid shift as a data-entry clerk for Silicon Valley because a line of computer code thinks my cursor moved a little too smoothly.


In other words, our humanity is now measured by sheer, twitchy incompetence. It’s like playing defence for the Leafs since (spoiler alert) Tim Horton was traded to the Sabres. (For the information of any readers here under 70 — yes, that Tim Horton. Don’t you find all these antediluvian Boomer references soooooo aggravating?)


Then again, maybe the machine is onto something. Humans are, after all, the species that invented Keeping Up With the Kardashians and sundry spinoffs, put cup holders on treadmills and proudly gave the world the Segway. We have a long, distinguished history of questionable judgment.


Still, I would prefer to prove my humanity through more accurate metrics. Instead of blurry street corners, the AI should ask me why I have 47 browser tabs open. Or why I walked into the kitchen three times while writing this and forgot what I wanted each time. Or why I own a drawer full of charging cables for electronics that went extinct about the time Chrétien throttled that heckler with an awesome throat grab.


Those are the true hallmarks of Homo sapiens, the species of great apes that willingly handed the keys to the family sedan to Donald J. Trump and his Ass Menagerie of corrupt toadies, sycophants, bootlickers and traitors.


Twice.


Finally, on my sixth attempt, the little box turns green. Verification successful.


I slump back in my chair, exhausted, having survived the emotional equivalent of a secondary screening at customs. The machine has deemed me sufficiently flawed to be one of us. I am permitted to proceed to checkout.


The shoes cost $49.95. Shipping is $18.05. I could have just gone to the mall and saved $5.79.


I close the browser. Somewhere, deep inside a server farm, an algorithm quietly logs that I am human — though I suspect it left an asterisk next to my file. There’s always plenty of wiggle room for ifs, ands or bots. For what is a man, what has he got? If not himself, then he’s a bot.


“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.”


“The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master — that’s all.”

 
 
 

Comments


©2020 by  David Sherman - Getting Old Sucks

bottom of page