Terms and Conditions May Apply
Time was when making a deal with the devil required a bit of effort.
You had to go down to a crossroads at midnight, preferably carrying a fiddle, and negotiate with a mysterious stranger who called himself Mr. Scratch, smelled faintly of brimstone and had unusually good dental work. There were formalities. There was atmosphere. You noticed you were bleeding. There was a pen with red ink.
And there was at least the possibility that you might reconsider before signing away your eternal soul.
Today, however, all you need to do is download a flashlight app.
I know this because I recently attempted to download a flashlight app onto our cellphone. Well. Technically it’s my wife’s phone, which cost approximately as much as the 2012 Chevy Cruze we sold to pay for it. I still use our landline for making and receiving phone calls, which is mostly what I want a phone for.
The new smartphone already possesses a perfectly functional flashlight. It is built into the device. It requires no subscription, has no customer loyalty program and does not appear to be gathering intelligence on our next-door neighbour’s nocturnal activities.
Nevertheless, I found myself browsing the App Store for a flashlight app because, according to She Who Must Be Obeyed, the one that came with the phone was insufficiently illuminating.
I selected one called SuperBright Flashlight Pro Max Ultra, which promised to brighten our surroundings with the power of 10,000 supernovae. I clicked DOWNLOAD.
And voilà! Le voici! The checkbox: “I have read and agree to the Terms and Conditions.”
Beneath it was a hyperlink to a document approximately the length of War and Peace, written in a dialect of legalistic English developed by unscrupulous, money-grubbing Dickensian lawyers Dodson and Fogg, who (unknown even to Dickens) seem to have been raised not by wolves but by Charles Babbage’s early prototypes for malfunctioning fax machines.
I clicked the link. The document opened. I began reading. Within 30 seconds, I didn’t know if it was day or night. I started kissing everything in sight.
Three minutes later, I was no longer certain that we still owned our house.
By paragraph four, I had unwittingly granted the company permission to collect information about my device, browsing habits, purchasing preferences, geographic location and my mother’s maiden name.
By paragraph seven, they reserved the right to share this information with “trusted third-party partners,” which is corporate language for people you have never met who will now know things about you that even your spouse doesn’t know. Or would ever want to.
Somewhere in the middle of the document, after kissing a cop on 34th and Vine who broke my little bottle of End-User License Agreement No. 9, I discovered that the company could modify its terms at any time, without notice, and that continued use of the application constituted acceptance of the revised agreement.
In other words, I was entering into a legally binding covenant with an entity that could change the provisions, stipulations, caveats, fine print, strings attached, conditions of use of our first-born son whenever it felt like it, while retaining the right to terminate the relationship whenever it felt like it. Seems fair.
My first marriage was easier to get out of. And all I had wanted in the first place was to find the TV remote under the bed.
The modern Terms and Conditions agreement (or ToS, short for “Et ToS, Brute?”) is one of the great psychological experiments of our time. It reveals something extraordinary about the human condition: We are willing to surrender virtually every conceivable personal liberty in exchange for something that costs $1.99 or, in the case of the flashlight app, absolutely nothing.
We will sign away our privacy, our intellectual property, the loose, retractable foreskins of the Patriarchs and our right to participate in class-action lawsuits because we desperately want to know whether the batteries in our smoke detector are dead.
Imagine applying this business model to ordinary life.
You walk into a restaurant. The waiter approaches.
“Would you like to see the menu?”
“Yes, please.”
“Excellent. Before we proceed, I need you to acknowledge that by accepting this menu, you grant us irrevocable permission to photograph your face, monitor your chewing patterns, sell your dining preferences to our advertising affiliates and use your image in promotional materials, including but not limited to billboards, cereal boxes and political campaign advertisements.”
“Excuse me?”
“Also, we reserve the right to change the price of your meal after you’ve eaten it.”
“I’d like to speak to the manager.”
“Certainly. Please check the box below.”
We would never tolerate this in the physical world. Yet in the digital world, we behave like those toothless goobers who stand behind the Man-Boob Mussolini at Republican political rallies, wildly applauding every outrageous lie, falsehood and fabrication.
The checkbox has become the digital equivalent of the medieval lord’s demand for feudal allegiance, except that instead of providing military service and a portion of your wheat harvest, you provide your contacts list and permission to monitor your microphone.
And we do it cheerfully. Click. What fun!
The simple truth, of course, is that nobody has ever actually read a complete Terms and Conditions agreement.
Not one person.
Oh, somewhere, maybe in a basement in Wawa, Ontario, in the shadow of the Original Giant Wawa Goose, there is a man named Frank who has read every word of every user agreement he has ever encountered. But Frank is a weirdo with plenty of time on his hands. He wears three pairs of glasses, has no friends and becomes visibly agitated when someone says, “Just click OK.”
Frank has never downloaded an app without first consulting a spreadsheet. He knows that the weather app on his phone has a provision allowing it to collect certain location data. He knows that his grocery store loyalty card reserves the right to track his purchasing behaviour. He knows that his electric toothbrush has a privacy policy. He knows that his smart television is collecting viewing data. He even knows about that time you spent 15 seconds watching Mickey Rourke and Kim Basinger get down to business in 9½ Weeks.
Frank is not married, but then, you will have surmised that. This is because Edie, shortly after meeting him, asked whether he wanted to go out for dinner and Frank responded by requesting a copy of the restaurant’s data retention policy. Edie married Steve instead.
The rest of us are not Frank, including other people named Frank.
We are people who click the checkbox while waiting for a bus, standing in a grocery store or sitting on the lala, waiting to go yaya. We do not read the agreement. We glance at the scroll bar, notice that it is roughly the size of a grain of rice and intuit immediately that we are dealing with something that will outlive us and possibly the planet Jupiter.
Sometimes we make a token effort. We scroll down. We scroll down again. We scroll down with increasing speed, as if we are operating a slot machine and hoping to land on the words “You retain all your rights.” We might as well be looking at a broken shard of a cuneiform tablet from southern Mesopotamia, circa 3100 BCE.
Finally, we reach the bottom. There is the checkbox. We click it. We have not read a word. We have merely demonstrated that our arthritic thumb is still functional.
The most disturbing part is the sheer scope of the permissions we grant.
Take a simple flashlight app.
A flashlight, historically, has been a remarkably uncomplicated device. It consists of a light bulb, a battery and a switch. In some models, there is a rubberized grip that makes the flashlight easier to hold when you are searching for that remote under the bed. Technically speaking, that rubberized grip might have been the last technical innovation most of us fully understood.
All the traditional flashlight ever asked of us was a pair of hulking D-cell batteries. It never needed to know your location. It never requested access to your contacts. It never asked permission to examine your photographs, listen to your conversations or identify nearby Bluetooth devices. (An elderly neighbour persists in referring to such devices as Bluenose, which always floats my boat).
The heavy-duty, sportsman metal flashlight of yore never needed to know whether you prefer Thai food or Italian, whether you have recently purchased hemorrhoid cream or whether you are emotionally vulnerable to advertisements featuring rabid Mastadors like the one whose death by shotgun brought you to tears in 1957’s Old Yeller.
A modern flashlight app, however, might request an astonishing range of permissions, depending on the app and device. But why? Why, when you think about it, does a flashlight need my location? Is it going to signal a passing satellite from Elon Musk’s Starlink subsidiary to illuminate the exact spot where I am standing? Does it have a longstanding commitment to helping me find my way to the nearest Starbucks?
Why does it need access to my contacts? Does it intend to call someone when the batteries run low? And why, in the name of all that is holy, does it need access to my microphone? I didn’t even know I had one. Siri, are you there? If so, go Alexa yourself!
Imagine the app developer sitting in a conference room explaining the business model:
“We’ve developed a revolutionary flashlight application.”
“Wonderful. What does it do?”
“It turns on a light.”
“Excellent. What else?”
“We collect the user’s location, contacts, device information and browsing history.”
“Why?”
“We’re still working on that part. But a woman who works under Jensen Huang seems very interested in it.” (Last week’s big espionage scandal was the latest demonstration that, let the chips fall where they may — including inside my wife’s new iPhone — two Huangs don’t make a right.)
Of course, the problem isn’t limited to apps. The entire digital economy seems to operate on the assumption that privacy is an outdated concept, like rotary phones, modesty and the belief that the American government should not be in the hands of a corrupt, traitorous, co-dependent House of Atreus utterly devoid of competence, decency and compassion.
But I digress.
Our refrigerators want to connect to Wi-Fi. Our doorbells want to recognize faces. Our cars want to let some agency in Beijing know precisely where we’re going. Anyone know the Mandarin word for KAOS?
Our televisions want to know what we’re watching. Our watches want to know whether our hearts are beating and how much REM sleep we’re putting in. Our thermostats want to know whether we’re home so they can tip off the fridge.
At some point, I expect the toilet to ask me to accept a privacy policy before allowing me to flush: “By pressing the lever, you agree to our revised Sanitation Services Agreement, including the collection of relevant waste-management data and its potential distribution to selected commercial partners.”
“OK, OK. But this is pretty rank. Can I just flush?”
“Not until you acknowledge that your bowel movements may be recorded to improve our customer experience.”
This is not technology serving humanity. This is humanity becoming an unpaid research department for technology companies set up for the express purpose of making a dozen obscenely rich men in Silicon Valley even more capable of extinguishing democracy everywhere.
We have gone from a world in which people occasionally worried about being watched by Big Brother to a world in which we voluntarily install cameras in our living rooms, carry microphones in our pockets … and then wonder why advertisements seem to know that we were thinking about buying a kayak.
We are not customers anymore. We are livestock with excellent broadband.
Finally, there is something deeply troubling about the phrase “I agree.”
It suggests a conscious, informed decision. It implies that I have examined the terms, understood the implications, considered the alternatives and arrived at a conclusion. In reality, what happened was that I wanted to download a flashlight and wasn’t prepared to spend the next 48 hours exploring a complete set of rules and statutes dating from the Codex Hammurabi.
I did not agree in any meaningful sense. I capitulated. Pas la même chose.
If a bank presented me with a 47-page contract before allowing me to withdraw $20, I would get my back up and ask some questions. If a stranger approached me on the street and said, “Would you mind signing this document giving me unlimited access to your personal information, financial records, family photographs and geographical movements for the next 75 years?” I would quickly walk away.
But if that same stranger put the document on my phone and offered me a free app that makes my screen glow blue — neato, Fonzie! — I would click AGREE before he finished speaking.
Pavlovian R Us. The checkbox appears, and instead of drooling at the sound of a bell or a metronome, our thumb starts twitching at the sight of an impenetrable legal document.
We don’t know what we have agreed to. We don’t know who owns what. We don’t know whether the company can sell our data, retain it, transfer it or use it to construct an artificial intelligence model capable of predicting our next purchase of antacid tablets.
I only know that the flashlight app is now installed. And the covenant I have entered is about as secure as a Microsoft network capacity upgrade or the current state of U.S. air traffic control communications.
I just hope some doofus in Palookaville replacing old copper wires with new fibre ones doesn’t cause flashlight routers all over the world to flood with data during routine maintenance, setting off a chain of explosions parallel to what happened to those pagers and walkie-talkies in the pockets of Hezbollah operatives a couple of years ago in Lebanon.
Bottom line: We click ACCEPT because we want the app. We click ALLOW because we want the feature. We click CONTINUE because we want the website to stop bothering us with persistent prompts.
And somewhere in the process, we have handed over the keys to our digital houses, given the neighbours permission to rummage through our closets and authorized a consortium of strangers to sell photographs of our pets to a company that manufactures discount orthopaedic footwear.
As God famously says in Genesis 1:3 to bring order and illumination to the void, “Hey Siri, let there be darkness!”
No, wait. Maybe that was the other guy, down by the crossroads at midnight.

Comments