top of page
Search

What’s the point of dying?

3 hours ago
6 min read

Dying, when you think about it, doesn’t require much in the way of technique. Pretty amazing for such an important event in our lives.


In his essay “Of Physiognomy” written sometime in the good old 1580s, about the time Madonna’s career was just taking off with her first hit single, “Like a Jerkin,” Michel de Montaigne offered these reassuring words:


If you don’t know how to die, don’t worry; Nature will tell you what to do on the spot, fully and adequately. She will do this job perfectly for you; don’t bother your head about it.


Emily Dickinson’s 1863 poem “Because I could not stop for Death,” which lost out at the Grammys that year to Phil Collins’s signature hit “Something Happened on the Way to Heaven,” sums things up nicely with its opening verse:


Because I could not stop for Death -

He kindly stopped for me -

The Carriage held but just Ourselves -

And Immortality.


No sweat. No action required on your part. No salesman will come to your door. Not available in stores. Your hands need never touch the meat.


We’re not dealing with Rubik’s Cube or French literary verb tenses here. Among the thousands of titles in the world’s best-known instructional reference book series, you will never see a Death for Dummies edition. At least, not on this side of the Great Divide.


I came across a more intriguing question the other day, however, while rereading Joan Didion’s superb 1979 essay “The White Album,” which came out when I was still carrying a comb in a back pocket of my Bib & Union overalls.


In Oregon on a 1970 Life magazine assignment to report on the storage of VX and GB nerve gas at a U.S. Army depot, Didion was asked a heavy philosophical question by a Mormon motel manager as she was checking out:


If you can’t believe you’re going to heaven in your own body and on a first-name basis with all the members of your family, then what’s the point of dying?


“At that time,” Didion confesses in the essay, “I believed my basic affective controls were no longer intact, but now I present this to you as a more cogent question than it might at first appear, a kind of koan of the period.”


If one were to recast the motel manager’s question in a more traditional Zen form, it might go something like this:


A traveller asked the innkeeper, “How do I leave this place?”

The innkeeper replied, “If you cannot take your own face and call your kin by name on the other side, why bother walking through the door?”


Or maybe:


When the body falls away and all names are forgotten, who is it that arrives — and why did they make the journey?


Or even:


To die without your own hands to hold the hands of your family: if the guest does not arrive, what is the purpose of the feast?


All good questions, even if they are au fond the same question. From a purely human standpoint, what is the point of dying? What’s in it for me? Also, when you eat your Smarties, do you eat the red ones last?


After all, the first thing I would want to know about the other side is what the accommodations are like. I don’t mean a palace or anything extravagant. To quote the Wife of Bath from Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, for no particular reason other than the fact that it suddenly popped into my head straight out of a Grade 11 English class where I was daydreaming in 1971, “I wol persevere; I nam nat precius.” I will survive not surviving.


However, I would certainly appreciate a clean room, decent PVC plumbing, a window that opens … maybe even a freestanding bar fridge in which to keep leftovers. Dunno about you, but I have no intention of spending eternity eating every meal in a communal dining hall with people who believe that the correct response to a question about the weather is to describe their great-great-great-great-great grandson’s recent hernia surgery.


And what about family? This is where the motel manager’s question begins to gain traction.


The promise of eternal reunion sounds wonderful until you consider the practical implications. Are we talking about immediate family only, or does the invitation extend to everyone with whom you share a genetic connection? Most of us have had relatives we would cross a busy highway to avoid, and the idea of spending eternity with them strikes me as less a religious reward than an administrative error.


Imagine arriving in heaven and being greeted by an aunt who has been dead for 40 years and still wants to pick a bone with you about something you said at Thanksgiving in 1972. You have no memory of what it was, no luggage and no visible means of escape. She, meanwhile, has had several decades to rehearse her opening remarks.


“Well, look what the cat drug in! You certainly took your own sweet time.”


I would like to think that death comes with some sort of orientation, like joining a cult or being named to the Canadian Senate. In fact, being named to the Canadian Senate might itself be viewed as a prolonged orientation session for the next stage.


For those of us unlikely to become senators, however, a brief introductory film, followed by a questionnaire, might be just the ticket. Are there people you would prefer not to see? Are there conversations you would prefer not to have again? Would you like to be reunited with your mother, your father and your childhood dog, or would you prefer to spend the first few centuries alone, just getting your bearings?


There is also the question of identity. The motel manager insisted on arriving in one’s own body, which is only fair. I’ve spent decades breaking mine in. I know which knee sounds like a gunshot when it rains and exactly how to tilt my head so my neck doesn’t detach from my spine when watching Hogan’s Heroes on MeTV. What a terrific concept for a sitcom!


IMO, getting issued a factory-reset body at the Pearly Gates would be a disaster. What if there’s a mix-up at celestial baggage claim and they accidentally put me in the physique of a 22-year-old Olympic gymnast? Suddenly, angels are tossing me a volleyball and expecting me to do backflips. I’d have to pull Saint Peter aside and explain that while the hardware is top-of-the-line, the software is still running on Windows 95 and terrified of pulling a hamstring for eternity.


Worse, what if they run out of human torsos altogether and spend the first few millennia apologetically housing my consciousness inside a moderately successful 19th-century Belgian turnip or a smart fridge with Wi-Fi issues?


And then there’s the sheer administrative tedium of everlasting bliss. Every utopia eventually forms a homeowners association. It’s not hard to imagine the passive-aggressive laminated signs taped to the clouds: NO RUNNING IN THE ETERNAL CORRIDORS. DO NOT MAKE EYE CONTACT WITH THE SERAPHIM. ALL EXISTENTIAL COMPLAINTS MUST BE SUBMITTED IN TRIPLICATE TO DEPARTMENT 4B.


Frankly, I don’t have the stamina for endless perfection. Give me an impeccable afternoon, and by 3 p.m. I’m convinced my toaster is plotting an arson. Put me on a tropical vacation, and by day two I’m auditing the complimentary continental breakfast like a forensic accountant and fretting about whether I remembered to leave the car in Park back at the airport.


After three centuries of mandatory harp solos and banquets where nobody brought even a single potato salad, I’d be hunting down the regional manager to demand a 30-day free trial, a partial refund or at least a weekend pass to go haunt a local Denny’s.


In the end, of course, the motel manager’s question misses the mark. He assumes the point of dying is the grand reunion, when really, the point is the mystery.


If it hadn’t been so early in the morning and she’d had her first coffee, Ms Didion might have stood the motel manager’s question on its head: If there’s an afterlife that is essentially a continuation of our lives on Earth, with 2.0 versions of our bodies, then what’s the point of dying? Unless, of course, sandals are optional and heavenly cappuccinos are on tap 24/7.


To quote the great Peggy Lee (channelling the even greater Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller): Is that all there is, is that all there is? If that’s all there is my friends, then let’s keep dancing

Let’s break out the booze and have a ball

If that’s all there is.


Oh. And one more thing. If a lengthy medical intervention fails and we suddenly find ourselves standing before the gates, surrounded by weeping loved ones, soaring choirs and a four-headed angel holding a clipboard, will there be a late checkout fee?

 
 
 

2 Comments


rekhafowler
1 hour ago

I don’t believe that everyone who dies automatically gets to heaven which is unlike any place on earth so what can we expect when we die???? I love all your theories and wonder why we don’t get a peak into the afterlife? 👻🧘🏽‍♂️

Like
rekhafowler
13 minutes ago
Replying to

Correction: it should read peek 👀 not peak ⛰️🤫

Like

©2020 by  David Sherman - Getting Old Sucks

bottom of page